By: MassLight Team

‍

The SAFE (Simple Agreement for Future Equity) note was introduced in 2013 by startup accelerator Y Combinator as a new financing instrument designed to simplify the investment process for early-stage startups. The goal of the SAFE note was to create a standardized, easy-to-understand agreement that would make it easier for startups to raise funds from investors without the need for complex legal documents.

The SAFE note is based on the concept of a convertible note, a popular financing instrument for startups that allows investors to lend money to a company with the option to convert that loan into equity at a future date. However, convertible notes have some limitations, including the need to negotiate the interest rate and maturity date of the loan, which can make the process more time-consuming and expensive for both startups and investors.

‍

‍

The SAFE note sought to address these limitations by eliminating the debt component of the convertible note and instead offering a right to purchase equity at a future date. Unlike convertible notes, SAFE notes do not accrue interest or have a maturity date, and they are not considered debt on the company's balance sheet.

Since its introduction, the SAFE note has become a popular financing instrument for early-stage startups, with many investors and startup accelerators using it as a standard investment agreement. The simplicity and flexibility of the SAFE note have made it an attractive option for startups seeking to raise capital quickly and easily, and it has helped to streamline the early-stage investment process for both startups and investors.

‍

SAFE Note Benefits

SAFE notes have become popular with startups for a variety of reasons, including the following:

1. Simplicity: SAFE notes are often simpler and easier to understand than traditional equity financing instruments like convertible notes. They are usually shorter, more concise documents that can be executed quickly and without significant legal expenses.
2. Flexibility: SAFE notes offer more flexibility in terms of structure and terms than convertible notes. They can be tailored to the specific needs of a startup and can include a range of features such as valuation caps, discount rates, and pro-rata rights.
3. Reduced Dilution: SAFE notes allow startups to raise capital without diluting their equity ownership as much as they would in a traditional equity financing round. This is because safe notes do not convert to equity until a future financing round occurs, and the conversion price is often lower than the price paid by subsequent equity investors.
4. Cost Savings: SAFE notes can be less expensive for startups than traditional equity financing instruments, such as preferred stock. This is because they do not require the same level of legal and accounting work, resulting in lower transaction costs.
5. Early Access to Capital: SAFE notes provide startups with early access to capital from investors who are willing to invest before the company has established a valuation. This can be especially valuable for startups in the early stages of development who may not yet be able to attract traditional equity investors.

‍

‍

SAFE Note Drawbacks

While SAFE notes have become a popular financing tool for startups, there are some criticisms of this instrument. Here are a few of the main criticisms:

‍

1. Lack of Clarity: SAFE notes can be less clear and transparent than other financing instruments. For example, the lack of a clear valuation at the time of investment can create uncertainty for both the startup and the investor.
2. Misalignment of Interests: Because SAFE notes do not offer equity ownership, some investors may feel less aligned with the company's long-term success. This may lead to less engagement from investors and less support for the company when it needs it most.
3. No Legal Precedent: SAFE notes are a relatively new financial instrument and there is no legal precedent for how they should be treated in certain situations, such as bankruptcy or a change in control. This lack of clarity can create uncertainty and additional legal costs for both the startup and the investor.
4. Limited Upside for Investors: While SAFE notes offer a reduced dilution for startups, they can also limit the potential upside for investors. For example, a valuation cap may limit the return for an investor who would have otherwise received a larger equity stake in a future financing round.
5. Complexity: While SAFE notes are often touted for their simplicity, they can also become complex when additional terms and features are added. This complexity can create confusion and misunderstandings between the startup and the investor.

‍

Overall, while SAFE notes have many benefits for startups, there are also valid criticisms of this financing tool that startups and investors should be aware of before entering into an agreement.

‍

‍

Types of SAFE Notes

There are two main types of safe notes:

‍

1. Valuation Cap Safe: A valuation cap safe note includes a valuation cap, which sets the maximum valuation at which the note will convert into equity. If the startup's valuation is higher than the cap, the investor will convert their investment at the valuation cap. This provides investors with a potential upside, as they can obtain equity in the company at a lower valuation.
2. Discount Rate Safe: A discount rate safe note includes a discount rate, which allows the investor to purchase shares at a lower price than the price paid by the next equity investors in the startup. This provides the investor with a potential upside, as they can obtain equity in the company at a lower price than other investors.

‍

In addition to these two main types, there are also other variations of safe notes that may include features such as a cap on the amount of dilution or a minimum valuation at which the note will convert. These include: Most Favored Nation (MFN), Pro Rata, No Discount/No Cap, and Weighted Average SAFEs.  However, the majority of safe notes issued typically fall under one of the two main types described above.

‍

Ready to bring your startup to the next level? Apply to MassLight’s next batch. MassLight supplies capital and a dedicated tech team. We take equity in return. Have questions? Refer to our FAQ page.